Hunting Knife
-
- Posts: 2
- Joined: Mon Jul 18, 2022 12:56 am
-
- Posts: 4988
- Joined: Wed Jan 25, 2017 2:54 pm
- Location: CT
- Has thanked: 30 times
- Been thanked: 1198 times
Re: Hunting Knife
It depends on what you are looking for and what size animals.
For gutting/field dressing, small game, a nice, nimble caping knife with a pointy tip works well. Deer sized game, a 3-4" drop point works well. Larger animals people often like a larger knife. Skinning, I like some belly to the blade.
I do a variety of hunting style blades from capers to larger blades in a variety of stainless and carbon steels. For processing deer after it is skinned and quartered, a good boning knife is essential, but most of the western ones dont hold an edge very long and many of the Japanese ones are stiffer than I like. I like a mid flexible boning knife in a tough stainless like AEBL or Nitro V that are easy to sharpen but hold an edge better than carbon steels that are still very tough.
Cleaning silverskin and fat, the boning knife works well, as do the Japanese Honesuki, Garusuki, hankotsu, etc. Stiffer and with a good point, they aren't making much board or bone contact, so the Japanese blades work well. Others prefer a 165mm to 180mm petty with a little flex for these tasks. For steaking out larger cuts, a nice, stiff sujihiki works very well. A gyuto has more drag along the sides.
For gutting/field dressing, small game, a nice, nimble caping knife with a pointy tip works well. Deer sized game, a 3-4" drop point works well. Larger animals people often like a larger knife. Skinning, I like some belly to the blade.
I do a variety of hunting style blades from capers to larger blades in a variety of stainless and carbon steels. For processing deer after it is skinned and quartered, a good boning knife is essential, but most of the western ones dont hold an edge very long and many of the Japanese ones are stiffer than I like. I like a mid flexible boning knife in a tough stainless like AEBL or Nitro V that are easy to sharpen but hold an edge better than carbon steels that are still very tough.
Cleaning silverskin and fat, the boning knife works well, as do the Japanese Honesuki, Garusuki, hankotsu, etc. Stiffer and with a good point, they aren't making much board or bone contact, so the Japanese blades work well. Others prefer a 165mm to 180mm petty with a little flex for these tasks. For steaking out larger cuts, a nice, stiff sujihiki works very well. A gyuto has more drag along the sides.
-
- Posts: 2
- Joined: Mon Jul 18, 2022 12:56 am
-
- Posts: 4988
- Joined: Wed Jan 25, 2017 2:54 pm
- Location: CT
- Has thanked: 30 times
- Been thanked: 1198 times
Re: Hunting Knife
Thanks! For factory field dressing/gutting knives, Bark River makes some really nice hunters as well as Benchmade. TOPS, ESEE and Falkniven are good to go as well as Cold Steel. Buck has nice stuff in S30V, too. For processing larger game, Dexter carbon knives are pretty nice for those tasks. Trimming and slicing, a nice Japanese petty/sujihiki work really well.
- Drewski
- Posts: 1309
- Joined: Wed Mar 28, 2018 2:01 am
- Location: Manitoba, Canada
- Has thanked: 429 times
- Been thanked: 46 times
Re: Hunting Knife
Benchmade Steep Country is a great knife for deer.
Bark River are nice as well, Classic Drop Point Hunter and Fox River are what I have and like. I find I use the Benchmade more as I like the shortness/maneuverability of the blade.
Bark River are nice as well, Classic Drop Point Hunter and Fox River are what I have and like. I find I use the Benchmade more as I like the shortness/maneuverability of the blade.
-
- Posts: 17
- Joined: Mon Jun 14, 2021 9:10 am
- Location: Ohio - USA
- Has thanked: 6 times
- Been thanked: 6 times
Re: Hunting Knife
I think you're looking at two different needs.
For gut/skin:
I like straight blade knives for this work. I've been using a Benchmade Bushcrafter the past couple seasons and am planning to move to something a little smaller overall. The Bushcrafter option has thick blade stock and feels like it's trying to cover everything you may need while out bushcrafting... I'm realizing I overbought and my bushcrafting days are long gone! (Plus what was I thinking buying a 1 knife only solution!) The knife is well built and the steel feels indestructible, but I think an overall thinner edge would be nicer.
I used a swiss army back in the early days for my field dressing and like the shorter blade height, especially when cutting the colon loose before pulling the gut pile out. The Benchmade Steep Country knives have my attention. Also their saddle mountain skinner and a knife about to release, Raghorn look interesting. Getting pricey, but a classic randall model #7 could be cool.
Processing (fully butchering):
I bring the kitchen knives over. Mainly 150-180 pettys, a curved boning knife, and an old forgecraft stiff boning knife from ebay ($20). I'll bring multiple knives of the same size because I typically don't want to take a break to sharpen anything. A saw if useful if you want the ribs with the meat on (instead of trimming the meat off the bone).
Good luck with your all of your hunting - knife and animal - this upcoming season!
For gut/skin:
I like straight blade knives for this work. I've been using a Benchmade Bushcrafter the past couple seasons and am planning to move to something a little smaller overall. The Bushcrafter option has thick blade stock and feels like it's trying to cover everything you may need while out bushcrafting... I'm realizing I overbought and my bushcrafting days are long gone! (Plus what was I thinking buying a 1 knife only solution!) The knife is well built and the steel feels indestructible, but I think an overall thinner edge would be nicer.
I used a swiss army back in the early days for my field dressing and like the shorter blade height, especially when cutting the colon loose before pulling the gut pile out. The Benchmade Steep Country knives have my attention. Also their saddle mountain skinner and a knife about to release, Raghorn look interesting. Getting pricey, but a classic randall model #7 could be cool.
Processing (fully butchering):
I bring the kitchen knives over. Mainly 150-180 pettys, a curved boning knife, and an old forgecraft stiff boning knife from ebay ($20). I'll bring multiple knives of the same size because I typically don't want to take a break to sharpen anything. A saw if useful if you want the ribs with the meat on (instead of trimming the meat off the bone).
Good luck with your all of your hunting - knife and animal - this upcoming season!
-
- Posts: 4988
- Joined: Wed Jan 25, 2017 2:54 pm
- Location: CT
- Has thanked: 30 times
- Been thanked: 1198 times
Re: Hunting Knife
Sharpening when processing deer sucks (deer fat is VERY sticky and a PITA to remove.) I do the same and have 3 or 4 smaller boning knives, but I like a longer gyuto/suji with a steel with good edge retention for slicing so I don't have to sharpen.
Skinning, I also like a higher end steel with good edge retention, so a modern tool or CPM steel (S35VN, MagnaCut, CruWear, CPM 4V, M390, etc) with a thin behind the edge blade grind in the 3-3.5" range. I use a lot of 3/32" stock for my hunting/EDC blades and hidden frame tangs.
Raghorn looks nice, but you can get customs in the same steel for a good bit less than the MSRP I saw! Bark River uses nice steels and has options in handle material so you can go with a basic model or fancier model depending on your budget.
Skinning, I also like a higher end steel with good edge retention, so a modern tool or CPM steel (S35VN, MagnaCut, CruWear, CPM 4V, M390, etc) with a thin behind the edge blade grind in the 3-3.5" range. I use a lot of 3/32" stock for my hunting/EDC blades and hidden frame tangs.
Raghorn looks nice, but you can get customs in the same steel for a good bit less than the MSRP I saw! Bark River uses nice steels and has options in handle material so you can go with a basic model or fancier model depending on your budget.
Re: Hunting Knife
Mora makes great quality blades for literally dirt cheap. I have a Robust model, which is a bit thicker than necessary for most things to be frank, but I love the thing for yard work. Never hunted with it, but I know people who have used Mora's Companion series for hunting and speak well of them. They are scandi ground, which is a bit different to sharpen. I do the whole bevel on a coarse stone then micro bevel to my preferred edge finish and that little carbon blade gets sharp fast!
Another knife that I have heard highly suggested by some experienced hunters is a Havalon knife. They use replaceable blades so you can easily just swap them when they dull. Very handy.
Another knife that I have heard highly suggested by some experienced hunters is a Havalon knife. They use replaceable blades so you can easily just swap them when they dull. Very handy.
-
- Posts: 443
- Joined: Wed Jun 22, 2022 8:32 am
- Location: USA
- Has thanked: 124 times
- Been thanked: 253 times
Re: Hunting Knife
I have to second this. There are plenty of really nice looking and performing hunting knives out there if money is no object, but dollar for dollar I have not found anything that can compete with Mora for hunting and bushcraft knives.Kekoa wrote: ↑Thu Nov 17, 2022 8:10 pm Mora makes great quality blades for literally dirt cheap. I have a Robust model, which is a bit thicker than necessary for most things to be frank, but I love the thing for yard work. Never hunted with it, but I know people who have used Mora's Companion series for hunting and speak well of them. They are scandi ground, which is a bit different to sharpen. I do the whole bevel on a coarse stone then micro bevel to my preferred edge finish and that little carbon blade gets sharp fast!
Another knife that I have heard highly suggested by some experienced hunters is a Havalon knife. They use replaceable blades so you can easily just swap them when they dull. Very handy.
EDIT: I looked around the internet and found the hunting knife I used when I was younger and before I found Mora. My grandfather had lots of knives and we all had really fancy custom made hunting knives but I felt they didn't perform well. So, after getting really annoyed about that I ended up getting the Knives of Alaska Cub Bear below and using it in combination with a cheapo gut hook from the local store. It worked well for field dressing deer and turkeys, nice and compact too. We never really had to drag them very far so we didn't quarter them, less than a mile. I carried a pocket knife always for trimming branches and things. Once we got an animal home we just used the kitchen knives.
https://www.knivesofalaska.com/Store/cu ... --suregrip
Sam
-
- Posts: 4988
- Joined: Wed Jan 25, 2017 2:54 pm
- Location: CT
- Has thanked: 30 times
- Been thanked: 1198 times
-
- Posts: 443
- Joined: Wed Jun 22, 2022 8:32 am
- Location: USA
- Has thanked: 124 times
- Been thanked: 253 times
Re: Hunting Knife
Very nice! I like the bottom one. It looks like you could choke up on the blade really well. Things sure have come a long way since I got a custom hunting knife as a kid.
Sam
-
- Posts: 2
- Joined: Sat Nov 05, 2022 11:28 am
Re: Hunting Knife
its totally depends upon your need. whether you need it for skinning,hunting, camping or anything else.
-
- Posts: 65
- Joined: Thu Dec 01, 2022 6:53 am
- Has thanked: 24 times
- Been thanked: 29 times
Re: Hunting Knife
Agreed its two different needs. A drop point straight-ish for skinning/gutting and basic breaking. The size depends on animal size. For processing imo you cant beat a swibo/fdick curved boner that is ground down to be 2/3 of its original blade height.
Just my opinion, but a processing and breaking down/boning knife should be easy to regularly touch up with a steel, and difficult to chip. Also with a very slight amount of flex. Not like a filleting knife. You need to really put some torque into it to get it to flex. But it's handy for large animal joints to have a slight minimal give.
Also the handles of those knives are excellent for grip when things get bloody and fatty. Pictured is the knife I mean. It's actually called a semi flex 16cm boning knife. It's good as is. But if you thin the blade depth a bit it becomes a boning and jointing masterpiece. In the abattoirs here its about the only knife you will see on the floor.. the only thing that varies is the colour of the handle. Blue, black or yellow. It's not really a field knife though, if that's what this is about.
Just my opinion, but a processing and breaking down/boning knife should be easy to regularly touch up with a steel, and difficult to chip. Also with a very slight amount of flex. Not like a filleting knife. You need to really put some torque into it to get it to flex. But it's handy for large animal joints to have a slight minimal give.
Also the handles of those knives are excellent for grip when things get bloody and fatty. Pictured is the knife I mean. It's actually called a semi flex 16cm boning knife. It's good as is. But if you thin the blade depth a bit it becomes a boning and jointing masterpiece. In the abattoirs here its about the only knife you will see on the floor.. the only thing that varies is the colour of the handle. Blue, black or yellow. It's not really a field knife though, if that's what this is about.
Re: Hunting Knife
this is a beagle v3 -- its a full size knife good for EDC and any game general cleaning duties
this is my bird n trout that gets used in the kitchen for boning duties but also for breasting ducks and a myriad of outdoor uses to include fish small or large game. Probably my most well rounded model
this is my bird n trout that gets used in the kitchen for boning duties but also for breasting ducks and a myriad of outdoor uses to include fish small or large game. Probably my most well rounded model
Re: Hunting Knife
Many people use a folder for this, such as Kerchaw, Spyderco or Benchmade. I used to stick purely to fixed blades such as those posted here, but have recently been more flexible. Even fieldwork can be done with a good solid folder that has a strong mechanism.